Newsletter

The Cost of Control: Troops at Home, Chaos Abroad

How Trump’s Authoritarian Trade-Off Weakens America Everywhere

Graham Baughman

— 3 min read
Share

Donald Trump’s second term has been defined by a sweeping campaign to consolidate power—not through policy, but through force. At home, he’s occupying cities. Abroad, he’s dismantling America’s soft power. And everywhere, he’s replacing autonomy with control—because control is the point.

Subscribe now

This isn’t about safety. It’s about submission. And the price tag isn’t just measured in dollars—it’s measured in freedom, credibility, and lives.

At Home: Occupation and Coercion

Trump calls it “liberation.” In reality, it looks like martial law. In Washington, D.C., he declared “liberation day” and sent in the National Guard. He seized control of local police, bypassed elected officials, and deployed troops to majority-Black cities like Chicago, Oakland, and Baltimore. The justification? A “public safety emergency.” The reality? A federal occupation of American streets.

This isn’t law enforcement—it’s martial theater:

  • D.C. deployment costs over $1 million per day (NBC Boston).
  • In Chicago, the cost of occupation would exceed the cost of housing the city’s homeless population (The Intercept).
  • A federal judge called the Los Angeles deployment “unconstitutional,” warning it creates a “presidential police force” (ACLU).

And the militarization doesn’t stop at city streets. Trump is coercing universities into submission. Harvard is fighting to keep $2.6 billion in research funding after the administration demanded control over hiring, admissions, and speech. The judge in that case called the government’s rationale “mind-boggling,” warning that the consequences for constitutional law are “staggering” (NBC Boston).

This isn’t just an attack on academic freedom—it’s an attack on America’s competitive edge. For decades, the U.S. benefited from a global “brain drain,” attracting the best and brightest to our universities and research labs. Harvard, MIT, Stanford—these weren’t just schools; they were magnets for talent that drove breakthroughs in medicine, technology, and science. Now, with federal strings attached to speech and hiring, that magnet is losing its pull. Researchers who once dreamed of coming here are looking elsewhere. The cost isn’t just prestige—it’s progress.

Abroad: Abandonment and Waste

While Trump floods American cities with troops, he’s torching America’s reputation abroad. The collapse of USAID wasn’t just bureaucratic—it was catastrophic. Over 5,000 aid projects were canceled. Warehouses full of contraceptives, food, and medical supplies were sold off, abandoned, or destroyed.

Burning medicine while children starve isn’t just wasteful—it’s a betrayal of American values. USAID wasn’t charity; it was strategy. It stabilized fragile regions, reduced refugee flows, and built goodwill. Helping starving families in Senegal costs pennies compared to the billions spent on domestic militarization. And it was the morally right thing to do.

  • USAID helped save 91 million lives between 2001 and 2021 (The Lancet).
  • It reduced child mortality by 32%, HIV deaths by 74%, and malaria deaths by 53% (WHO Fact Sheet).
  • Its education programs reached 396 initiatives across 58 countries, improving literacy, employment, and gender equity (USAID Education Strategy).

Now, those gains are unraveling. A Lancet study projects 14 million excess deaths by 2040 due to the end of U.S. aid. That’s not just tragic—it’s destabilizing. And instability abroad means more displacement, more migration, and more global insecurity.

What We’ve Lost

Trump’s authoritarian agenda has replaced compassion with coercion, stability with spectacle, and global leadership with isolation. A reasonable person might ask: what do we gain from occupying our own cities and gagging our universities? The answer is clear—nothing but control.

But USAID? That was diplomacy through dignity. It was a quiet force for peace, health, and hope. And it cost so little.

We used to lead the world in innovation because we welcomed the world’s innovators. Now, we’re telling them: come here, and you’ll work under political supervision. That’s not freedom—that’s fear. And fear doesn’t cure cancer, build vaccines, or invent the next generation of clean energy. It just drives talent away.

If this is what “America First” looks like, who exactly is America for?

For readers who want the receipts

Read more